Skip to content
BroadcastwellStart free
Menu

Community guidelines

How we talk here

Challenge ideas with evidence. Treat people with respect. Mark hypotheticals as hypotheticals and link your sources. No confidential client or employer information, no personal data about others, no spam. Personal application questions belong in a message to hello@broadcastwell.com. Posts publish immediately; a small set of automatic checks may hold a post for a quick human look. Moderators remove abuse, spam and private information and record every action. You can delete your own contributions at any time.

The automatic check

Posts publish the moment they are sent. A post is held for a quick human look only when it trips one of these checks:

  • Five or more links off broadcastwell.com from an account less than a day old.
  • More than 20 posts from one account in an hour, or more than 200 in a day. Nobody is capped; past that, the next posts wait for a look.
  • The spam filter: an email address, a phone number or a government ID number in the text, a word or phrase on the blocked list, a near repeat of a recent post by the same account, or a known spam pattern.

Nothing else is held. A held post is visible to its author, who sees the reason, and a moderator reviews it.

Reports

Anyone signed in can report a contribution as spam, off topic, personal data, harassment or a wrong receipt, or say what else is wrong. A moderator decides, and your notifications tell you what was done. Reports are private: the author never learns who reported.

Moderation and appeals

Moderators can remove, restore, feature, lock, pin, move or merge, and can warn a member, suspend an account for a number of days or ban it, always with a written reason, and every action is recorded. Removed content is kept privately so a decision can be reviewed. A suspended or banned member sees why when they sign in. To appeal, write to hello@broadcastwell.com. Monthly moderation counts are public.

Votes and ranking

Every member can vote a thread, an answer or a comment up or down, once each, and change the vote later. No reputation is needed to vote. Who voted is never shown; the score is up votes minus down votes. A reply scored below minus five folds behind a Show button; an answer never folds.

Hot ranks a thread by (score + 1) divided by the square of (hours since it was posted + 2), so a new thread with a few votes can pass an older one with more. Top ranks by score over the window you pick. New ranks by time posted.

Questions and answers

A Question thread has one question and many answers. The person who asked, or anyone on the Broadcastwell team, can mark one answer as accepted; it then shows first, and the other answers follow by score. When a question was already asked, a moderator may merge the newer thread into the older one; its replies move there and its address forwards.

Team replies

A useful reply cites a specific point, adds a question or a piece of evidence, and tells the author what to check next. "Thanks for sharing" alone does not count.

Replies from our team carry a "Broadcastwell team" label with their role.

Answer receipts

Build an answer receipt or open the Index reading room.

Share the exact question, engine and experience, date, locale, permitted answer excerpt, source links, alternative explanation and next check. Leave unknown fields unknown. Remove private information before posting. A single observation does not establish a trend.

Recurring discussions

Engine watch: one dated observation per reply, including no observed change. Index reading room: discuss one category and the limits of its evidence after a real release. Ask the delivery team: one monthly thread for public questions, followed by a written answer and next steps.

Recognition

Helpful explanation: a direct answer that shows its reasoning and limits. Reusable example: a worked example with enough context for another person to reproduce it. Correction with evidence: a specific correction supported by a source and an explanation of what changed. A first response or sustained helpfulness can qualify through these same criteria, never through posting volume. An independent moderator records a public issuer and reason; withdrawal is recorded, and edits require a fresh review.

Helpful explanations, reusable examples and corrections with evidence may be featured after human review. Featuring is not a posting volume leaderboard, a credential or a hiring decision. Reuse outside the Exchange requires separate consent to the exact excerpt.

Participation and applications

Taking part in the Exchange is optional. It is never required, it is never reviewed when we assess an application, and it does not affect your application in any way. If you want to point to something you wrote here, you may link it yourself, as you would any portfolio link.